Welcome to Bagel to Sandwich
At "Bagel to Sandwich," we craft a unique bagel experience that transcends the ordinary. Located in the heart of New York City, our inviting space features an array of flavorful bagels—from classic to innovative varieties paired with tantalizing schmears. Customers rave about our signature sausage, egg, and cheese bagel sandwich, praised for its creaminess and savory depth. Our emphasis on quality extends to gluten-free options and an aesthetically pleasing, clean environment perfect for social media snapshots. With a quick, attentive service and convenient delivery, "Bagel to Sandwich" is a must-visit for bagel lovers craving both taste and atmosphere.
Bagel to Sandwich: Reviews & Ratings
Besides our everything bagel being a little overtoasted, our sausage, egg and cheese everything bagel sandwich with garlic herb smear was insane! Creamy, warm, savory, just perfect. We werent fans of the cinnamon roll we got, though maybe we ordered the pastry. Overall amazing!
An amazing cool aesthetic bagel spot round the corner serving bagels and much more. Loved their wide spread varieties from the basic to funky bagels along with tempting mouth watering schmears. Clean and well maintained store with good and attentive staff. A must try for the experience.
Great, affordable spot with great NYC vibes! I came with a friend around noon and we found a table instantly. They only have two tables btw. Plain toasted bagel with cream cheese is 5 and cappuccino is 5. Great staff! Very cheap for a Times Square location and NYC in general. Right in front port authority bus terminal!
One of the cooler bagel spots in NYC! And also tasty.. worth the visit. Endless selection of all kinds of bagel.. from classic to funky fun ones. Snacks galore. The team are machines.. line moves quick! ...
Ive walked past this place many times and decided to give it a try. The bagels are very good. They are thick, with a light crisp on the outside and a good chew on the inside. There are many flavors to choose from. The place is very photogenic, definitely primed for social media. Excellent bagels and very tasty.
Great experience for a first timer. Everything was easy to order and they answered any questions we had. Got the Korean bbq sandwich with the garlic bagel, Lox garlic bagel with salmon, and the garlic cream cheese filled bagel. Managed to be full with half a bagel. 1010. Would highly recommend this place for a quick, but savory bite.
Excellent bagels and cream cheese options! Theyre great tasting. And the coffee is excellent. Plus they put it in a can, which is so cool! No spilling, and you can wait to open it later. We loved this place!
AMAZING find today! WOW. Just delicious bagels and sandwiches. The employees were efficient and helpful. The place is darling with all of the kitschy decorations, food, snacks, cream cheeses and bagels. Its clean inside. Not a lot of ...
Location
-
240 W 40th St suite 604, New York, NY 10018 Hotline: (646) 329-6828
Welcome to Bagel to Sandwich, a premier destination nestled in the heart of New York City, specifically located at 240 W 40th St, Suite 604. This quaint eatery specializes in turning the classic bagel into a mouthwatering canvas for a variety of delectable sandwiches. Offering a delightful blend of traditional and innovative options, Bagel to Sandwich has quickly become a beloved spot for both locals and visitors alike.
- Hand-Rolled & Kettle-Boiled Bagels: At Bagel to Sandwich, every bagel is crafted with care. You can choose from hand-rolled or kettle-boiled varieties, each providing a unique texture and flavor experience. The prices are equally appealing, with plain bagels starting at just $2.00 and stuffed bagels at $8.50, making it a budget-friendly gem.
- Diverse Menu: Not just for breakfast, the menu also boasts a range of exciting options, including vegan offerings like the Vegan Turkey Special and Prime Reuben. Each sandwich is thoughtfully composed with fresh ingredients, like avocado, tomato, and various savory spreads, ensuring a fulfilling meal for every palate.
- Atmosphere: The aesthetic of Bagel to Sandwich is cool and inviting, perfect for social media enthusiasts looking for that Instagram-worthy shot. Reviews highlight the clean, well-maintained space and attentive staff, enhancing the overall dining experience.
- Convenience: The shop is incredibly accommodating with delivery and takeout options available. It also welcomes dogs, making it a perfect stop after a stroll in the city. With outdoor seating available, including heated and covered options, guests can enjoy their meals while soaking in the urban vibe.
Customer reviews echo a consistent satisfaction. Visitors rave about the rich flavors and generous portions, with one highlighting a sausage, egg, and cheese sandwich with garlic herb smear that was described as "insane" for its creamy, savory goodness. Another customer remarked on the impressive variety, stating it's a must-try for anyone looking to delve into the true bagel experience.
In a city filled with dining options, Bagel to Sandwich stands out not only for its quality offerings but also for its warm, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite before hitting the buses at Port Authority or leisurely enjoying a meal, this spot caters to all needs. So if you haven’t yet visited, your next breakfast or brunch adventure awaits!
For more information or to place an order, give them a call at (646) 329-6828. With an assortment of bagels and sandwiches ready to satisfy your cravings, Bagel to Sandwich is indeed the perfect bridge between bagels and sandwiches.
